
What follows is a guest essay by Michael Stringer.
We’re living in politically turbulent times. Wars, tariffs, assassinations, polarization—the horrors are hard to avoid, and they’re creating a climate where the question of politics is everywhere, especially within the arts. It makes sense. When the world’s on fire, we question the value of reading a novel or watching a film, of escaping from our world into another. However, the world of an artwork isn’t distinct from our larger, political world. Instead, it’s a pocket of space within our world, and the political value of that space has less to do with entering it than with how it enters us, and changes us in the process.
Artworks can change us through rupture. Ruptures are moments when an established sense of normalcy is disrupted and broken open, when an artwork starts going off the rails. Think of an actor’s performance overwhelming a scene, or a brash and disruptive brushstroke in an otherwise smooth painting. They’re the cracks in the surface that give an artwork its texture.
I’ve always liked these moments because they can create unique aesthetic experiences, and there’s political value in these experiences. Philosopher and cultural theorist Byung-Chul Han has articulated that value elegantly in his analysis of social rituals, where he describes the source of art as an excess of life. Art doesn’t have a goal or task, as we do in our social lives, and so art seems to exist differently, in a kind of “exalted time.” For Han, engaging with art is transformative, an opportunity to engage deeply with the symbolic part of our social world, rather than simply being a form of mental rest. Importantly, our symbolic world shapes how we think about the world, and how we think about the world shapes how we act within it. For example, when I’m in my living room, I don’t look for secret passages through my walls, but when I’m in an escape room, I do exactly that. The way I think about my environment opens up certain actions, makes them visible and obvious, while also obscuring other actions. In the same way, the aesthetic experience of rupture can open up avenues for political action.
We find rupture in the conventional story structure of most Hollywood films: status quo, disruption, hero overcomes obstacles to restore status quo, hero succeeds or fails. Rupture is a catalyst for the story, but such story structures form a neatly ordered system, and any truly disruptive quality is contained by that standard narrative form. While rupture can function within narrative, it also arises in visual style, character, performance, authorial signatures, genre conventions, or any other aspect of a film. These other uses of rupture contain something a little more volatile.
The jump scare is a short narrative and stylistic beat that’s based on disrupting a perceived normalcy. A woman comes home from an average day, looks out the window, and boom: there’s a creepy man in a mask and ominous background music. This is the scene where Laurie (Jamie Lee Curtis) spots Michael Myers (Nick Castle) in Halloween (1978), but it could have been from any number of horror films. This rupture is a common way of giving the audience a jolt, but it rarely destabilizes us for more than a moment. After Michael Myers appears in Laurie’s window, he suddenly disappears, and the film continues as normal. The jump scare establishes the world of a horror film, but it doesn’t alter that world. This is especially true for fake-out jump scares, where the disruptive moment turns out to be something entirely innocent—a frightening screech disrupts the scene, but it was just the sound of a bus (Cat People (1942)). The film breaks open for a moment, but it reconstitutes itself the same as before.

Every so often, though, a jump scare isn’t immediately contained by the film: things never return to normal. The bear suit scene in The Shining (1980) is like this. While running away from her axe-wielding husband, Wendy (Shelley Duvall) notices an open doorway inside the haunted hotel. The music kicks up and we cut to someone in a bear suit having sex in this doorway. The moment is disruptive not because it’s frightening but because it’s incongruous, totally disconnected from the scene’s real threat. Kubrick then doubles down on that disconnection, choosing never to return to this masked character and never explaining this strange moment. Here, the rupture of the jump scare isn’t resolved, and its disruption is left lingering in the viewer, giving the sense of another world hovering around the one we’ve been experiencing.

The shower scene in Psycho (1960) takes this kind of disruption even further. In that scene, the main character, Marion (Janet Leigh), is unexpectedly stabbed to death accompanied by a score of shrieking violins, and the fallout from this rupture is anything but normal. With our ostensible protagonist dead, the rest of the film reorients itself around Norman Bates (Anthony Perkins), and what started as a heist thriller fully shifts into a horror film. Here, the rupture isn’t left lingering, uncontained by the rest of the film, but it instead provokes a total reworking of the film from within. The film breaks open for a moment, and it reconstitutes itself as something entirely different.
Rather than being meaningless bits of style, these ruptures contain political potential. Artworks give us aesthetic experiences that we use to understand the world around us. As philosopher Alva Noë has argued, the world of art and our social world are deeply entangled. It’s not just that art imitates life and life imitates art, but that this inextricable loop is foundational to creating our social world. We can see Noë’s point if we consider conventional Hollywood films alongside the common motivational expression, “If it’s not happy, it’s not the end.” Such films end with clear, and typically happy, narrative resolution. The expression draws on our familiarity with this narrative structure, encouraging us to regard perseverance as a live possibility even when circumstances seem bleak. Just as the escape room shaped my perspective on that environment, influencing what avenues for action seemed available, the expression aims to shape this same perspective, and artworks provide concrete experiences that we use in this process. Engaging with these experiences is what Noë would call “aesthetic work—you look and think and talk. You describe. And in doing so, you reorganize yourself … You can see what you didn’t see before.” In this way, our experiences with artworks are bound up with how we interpret them, and they contribute to how we understand the world.
Rupture is a particular aesthetic quality. The political value of this quality lies in precisely that dynamic: it gives us an experience, which shapes our perspective and, in turn, the options we see as available. For artist and professor Ashon T. Crawley, political change is rooted in “otherwise possibilities,” the other ways of arranging our world. Ruptures can give us a visceral experience of that rearrangement. Films are artworks that ask us to think through them, to build each film’s world in our mind by following the logic of its formal construction. Films that build a sense of rupture into their logic, pushing us through their disruptions to something different, ultimately break their worlds open and ask us to rearrange them. They help us experience change. While these aesthetic rearrangements are not the same thing as political rearrangements, they are connected. Art might not change the world, but we do, and the process by which we change the world, by which we imagine, enact, and navigate it otherwise, is entangled with art.
Although ruptures can give an experience of change in general, artworks don’t deploy aesthetic qualities in general. The way a particular film uses the quality of rupture, interacting with its narrative and thematic system, will impact the specific experience of change it produces, and the experience we take away from the film’s rupture will depend on how we interpret it. To tease out this process in greater detail, I will send us into the world of David Lynch, a filmmaker who plays with the feeling of disruptive change better than anyone. The structure of his masterpiece Mulholland Drive illustrates how the experience of change can be internalized politically, how we can emerge from it reorganized.
* * * * *
Lynch’s cinema is full of ruptures. The documentary Lynch/Oz (2022) observes a recurring duality in his films, usually presented as dual realities that mirror each other in disturbing ways. Slippage between these realities often follows a disruptive event for one of the characters, a physical or psychological trauma. In Mulholland Drive (2001), this central disruption is both known and unknown, as it sets the film in motion but is also the object of its investigation.

The film begins with a car crash that erases the memory of a woman named Rita (Laura Harring), and she teams up with Betty (Naomi Watts), an aspiring actress, to rediscover her identity. In the end, what they find is the film’s real trauma, an event more responsible for the opening amnesia than the car crash. In the film’s final segment, Rita and Betty change into Camilla and Diane, two actresses who were once lovers but have since broken up. The story that led us here begins to feel like a fantasy version of Camilla and Diane, a fantasy beginning to fall apart. We see Diane struggling to get over losing Camilla, whose acting career has outpaced her own, so Diane conspires to murder her former lover. Ultimately, Diane can’t cope with her crime, and she suffers a mental breakdown before taking her own life. It’s this dark story that the preceding film tries to forget, replacing it with the fantasy of Betty and Rita, but when the site of Diane’s suicide is discovered, this fantasy collapses. While this interpretation presents the story in a relatively straightforward way, the film does not. Instead, both the fantasy of Rita and Betty and the nightmare of Camilla and Diane are fragmented, mixed up with obscure segments that create the film’s dreamy atmosphere.
Lynch uses several kinds of rupture to guide us through this unstable film. First, we have something similar to Psycho, where the murder of Marion reorients the film around Norman Bates. In Mulholland Drive, the discovery of Diane’s dead body by Rita and Betty ruptures the fantasy world and slowly reorients the film toward their alter egos, Camilla and Diane. After this discovery, a distorted superimposition multiplies the image of Rita and Betty, as if new layers of reality were splitting open, and we begin a protracted sequence that leads to Club Silencio, the film’s most abstract and contradictory space. After this extended disruption, the film pivots entirely to Camilla and Diane, who reenact key moments of the previous film from a different perspective. Where Psycho pivots to a different character within a consistent story world, Mulholland Drive pivots to an entirely new story world within itself, one that challenges our understanding of the characters and reworks our assumptions about the narrative.

While this rupture structures the film’s mirroring worlds, there’s another rupture that echoes The Shining’s ambiguity more than Psycho’s reorientation. Early on, we have an odd scene in Winkie’s Diner, a generic spot where two suited men (Patrick Fischler and Michael Cooke) finish their breakfasts. After some awkward glances, one of the men nervously confesses that he came to this diner because of a dream. They discuss the dream and go outside to see if the rest of it will come true. Suddenly, a monstrous figure pops up from behind an alley wall, and the nervous man has a heart attack. This disruption, the film’s only jump scare, lingers throughout the film because this frightening figure, along with the suited men, remain disturbingly disconnected from the rest of the story world(s).
While odd figures often intrude on the film’s main storyline, they always play a clearer function than these men. The filmmaker Adam Kesher (Justin Theroux) appears detached from the storyline at first, but he comes to be involved with Betty. The mysterious Mr. Roque (Michael J. Anderson) eventually becomes relevant for the Kesher subplot. Even the Cowboy’s (Monty Montgomery) antics come to be connected to Mr. Roque’s machinations. These figures are presented mysteriously at first, but they always have a clear role within the film’s bizarre narrative. The diner men have no such function. While we eventually learn that the diner is where Diane hatched her murder scheme, this revelation doesn’t give them any clear purpose. Like the bear suit in The Shining, the scene at Winkie’s hovers around the film, detached and enigmatic, as if coming from some parallel universe.

While the first rupture tries to explain the film’s mysterious world, mirroring the opening film to suggest some truer underlying story, the second rupture evades the impulse of explanation, leaving elements aimless and incongruous. The combination of these two qualities gives the film its political edge. From an ideological perspective, breaking open a fantasy narrative, revealing some hidden truth, reflects a common critical engagement with culture. Society is full of false narratives, fantasies that cover up the unpleasant cracks of reality—the boss takes more risks, so he should make more money; the nuclear family is natural, and everything else is deviant; the new camera on this phone will make your shitty life better. It’s important to challenge these narratives, to look at the uncomfortable realities they hide, but Mulholland Drive doesn’t stop there. While the promise of discovering the film’s hidden story activates our desire to know, to keep pulling the loose ends until everything unravels, the equal gesture of making that hidden story incomplete, couching it in disconnected and aimless elements, saves the film from replacing one fantasy with another. It’s a gesture that resists our desire for a single, complete, and totalizing answer.
Mulholland Drive makes us feel the disruption of a paradigm shift, a fundamental change in worldview, but it also confronts us with the lack of a stable replacement. Breaking down a false narrative doesn’t necessarily reveal a universal truth that solves all problems. Instead, the unmasking is a process of strange resonances, one where coherence can be felt even if things don’t make absolute sense. Not only does the film familiarize us with that uncomfortable feeling, but it also resists a simplistic reaction to that feeling. To see the “otherwise possibility” within that experience, just contrast it with alternatives. Conspiracy theories, for example, offer all-powerful forces to explain away the discomfort of disruptive change (the illuminati, aliens, the deep state), and fascists offer scapegoats (immigrants, the poor, minorities). Mulholland Drive offers no such simplicity, which makes lack of simplicity itself feel possible. The film asks us to follow its transformation into an unclear resolution, to make meaning from its open-ended complexity. The more familiar we become with that feeling, the more its possibility becomes visible. When we’re offered a new fantasy narrative in the future, it might even feel less attractive, since we’ve already felt the falseness of those narratives.
Mulholland Drive isn’t political because it makes the powers that be look silly or because a character gives an impassioned speech about the value of democracy. It’s political because it gives you a feeling, the disruptive feeling of change. If that feeling is strong enough, you’ll start thinking about it, grappling with it, doing the aesthetic work of being moved by it. You’ll leave the film reorganized. Where you go from there is up to you. Change does not guarantee us something better or worse, only something new and unknown. That uncertainty is frightening, which may be why ruptures show up so often in horror films. These works of art become meaningful by confronting us with that terror rather than letting us turn away.
Michael Stringer is a freelance film writer and educator based in Vancouver, BC. He has taught Film Studies at Alexander College and guest lectured on film at Simon Fraser University and the University of British Columbia. His writing on film has appeared in Bright Lights Film Journal, Film Matters, and Oxford Bibliographies Online.
Edited by Alex King



November 13, 2026 at 2:14 pm
Omni AI Video offers multiple video models, with available settings you can adjust for a particular idea. https://www.omniaivideo.org/