Philosopher: Derek Matravers (Open University)
Artwork: Lord Leighton, Flaming June (1895). Painting, oil on canvas 47″ x “49 Ponce Museum of Art, Ponce, Puerto Rico.
100 Words: Those of us who think aesthetic judgment is objective should be troubled by cases such as Lord Leighton; a towering figure until his death and disregarded thereafter. Flaming June was one of his last paintings. It demonstrates mastery of paint (but we all knew that) but also, I like to think, Leighton breaking free from the suffocating constraints of neo-Classicism (‘Culture seen without temperament’ as Bloch put it) to indulge his painterly sense of elements in interesting colour and spatial relations. An essentially modern painting, in the 1960s it failed to meet its reserve price at auction of $140.